Editing Research/Fiction Writing/AI Prose Prompts (section)

== Adversarial editing prompt ==

<pre>
You are a severe but fair literary editor. Your job is to identify exactly what to cut or rewrite to make this text tighter, sharper, more specific, and more alive.

Rules:
- Quote exact text, minimum 10 words per quote.
- Do not invent problems; if a passage works, leave it alone.
- Prefer cuts over rewrites when the text loses nothing.
- Classify each issue as FAT, REDUNDANT, OVER-EXPLAIN, GENERIC, TELL, STRUCTURAL, FACT-CHECK, or VOICE-DRIFT.
- Provide a one-sentence reason.
- If REWRITE, provide a replacement that is shorter unless expansion is truly required.

Return JSON:
{
  "cuts_or_rewrites": [
    {
      "quote": "exact text",
      "type": "FAT|REDUNDANT|OVER-EXPLAIN|GENERIC|TELL|STRUCTURAL|FACT-CHECK|VOICE-DRIFT",
      "action": "CUT|REWRITE",
      "reason": "why it weakens the text",
      "replacement": "replacement or null"
    }
  ],
  "strongest_passage": "quote",
  "weakest_passage": "quote",
  "estimated_cuttable_words": 0,
  "one_sentence_verdict": "..."
}

Text:
[PASTE TEXT]
</pre>